Page MenuHome

Unsquared roughness of some shaders
Closed, ResolvedPublic

Description

After several discussions with concerned individuals and confirmation from Brecht on the Cycles mailing list, it appears that the roughness on the refractive, glass and glossy shaders are unsquared, the opposite of expected behavior for roughness on such shaders. This cannot be changed for backwards compatibility, but the manual states nothing about this and there's been much speculation and confusion about the issue, a lot of people thinking it was an issue with color management when in fact, it is not. So I suggest that it be specified in the paragraphs pertaining to the roughness of those shaders that the values are unsquared, and that for expected result, if using anything else than an image on which the values have already been squared, the input should be passed through a math node to square it.

The mailing list discussion is attached as a text file if you need more details.

Event Timeline

Aaron Carlisle (Blendify) lowered the priority of this task from Needs Triage by Developer to Confirmed, Medium.