Mac OS Sierra
Radeon Pro 580
Broken: 2.78.5 66383ea206
Short description of error
Set normals from face effects faces across edges set to sharp. It would make more sense and be more useful if it would respect those edges IMHO.
Exact steps for others to reproduce the error
Create a cube
Bevel edges across one axis with one segment and mark the caps to sharp in the edge menu
Turn on auto smooth and set the angle to 180.
Select the smooth large faces and "Set normals to face" to move the smoothness to the bevel.
The caps should confinue to be flat since all there edges are marked as sharp.
I really like this functionallity and I only want it to improve :-D