Page MenuHome

Incorrect work of the modifier
Closed, ArchivedPublic


Incorrect work of the modifier as img (one spiral, instead 4).
Vertex combined by obtained by

  1. Add Single Vert (Edit mode automat)
  2. GX1
  3. Add Modifier Screw with 360 o, [Screw - 6.4m] [Iterations - 2]
  4. Add Modifier Array with chechkbox ObjectOffests (Empty rotate on 90 o by AXIS Z), COUNT - 4.
  5. Apply ALL Modifier || not [Apply Modifiers]
  6. Add Skin Modifier - not work (as img)/

P.C. additionally does not work modifier Normal Edit (and in Geometry Nodes) in this occasion.

Event Timeline

Alexey (pseudoua) updated the task description. (Show Details)
Alexey (pseudoua) added a comment.EditedSat, Apr 24, 3:51 PM

It's strange now if the modifier stack is not applied, it seems to work

and Normal edit earned.

But it is still not clear why it does not work with the applied modifiers.
And why doesn't it edit vertex normals and node geometries don't have access to them?

Falk David (filedescriptor) changed the task status from Needs Triage to Needs Information from User.Mon, Apr 26, 11:01 AM

@Alexey (pseudoua) It doesn't work when applying the modifiers because you lose the roots. The skin modifier works by taking the radius of the vertex/vertices marked as "root" (circled in red in edit-mode). In your example, after applying all the modifiers you would have to select the bottom 4 vertices and click "Mark Root" in the skin modifier. When not applying the modifiers, then the array modifier will copy the root flag for you.

Can you confirm that marking the vertices as root works?

I can't even apply it.

modifiers are not applied or applied in the wrong direction. I click to apply screw, and in response, a completely different modifier is applied (in this case, array)

@Alexey (pseudoua) that is a different bug in the UI in the alpha atm. Use Ctrl+A while hovering over the modifier to apply in the meantime.

Mark root works as you said, thanks, did not know

@Alexey (pseudoua) Alright. Thank you for confirming. I will close this for now.
Feel free to open a new report if you have any other issues.